This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
The UK was second best prepared for a pandemic in the world.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Right off the bat I get the sense that you think the role of government is to reduce all deaths down to the smallest possible short term amount...the 'safety above all else' mantra that is the mainstream approach and that politicians should be punished if any decision considered anything else. If I'm correct about your mindset regarding this then I guess we completely disagree that it's an appropriate or sensible way to run a society (freedoms) and economies (debt) indeed the rest of this decade is going to show that with much higher indirect death tolls......from delays from treatment to suicide to all the rest of them. Every death is a personal tragedy and I know people who have died during this pandemic. That said, governments have multiple factors to consider in any decision for the long term health of its people but the sociological and economic road it leads them down....it's not just about this generation but the future of the next. So while I'm no fan of Johnson, when it comes to criticisms related to this pandemic I probably have a completely different set of them.....and the criticisms are just as focused upon the global response as they are the national. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Oct 2021 8.34am) Not quite. I probably wasn’t overly clear in how I articulated my thoughts. I think we need an enquiry to understand what mistakes were made and how to ensure we learn from them (and take ownership - an apology not a kick in as none had done this before). BUT I fully appreciate and accept that decisions had to be made quickly and we absolutely had to keep the economy working. We may not be that far apart. I think there’s a global learning here and the learnings I’d like to see are how to balance deaths whilst keeping the country open. So PPE manufactured here, continued development of vaccines and treatments etc and a robust plan that considers how we keep going, keep freedoms whilst protecting people going forwards. I just dislike the constant anti-U.K. sniping from some on here. It’s really bloody jarring. Edited by Helmet46 (13 Oct 2021 8.55am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Helmet46
Not quite. I probably wasn’t overly clear in how I articulated my thoughts. I think we need an enquiry to understand what mistakes were made and how to ensure we learn from them (and take ownership - an apology not a kick in as none had done this before). BUT I fully appreciate and accept that decisions had to be made quickly and we absolutely had to keep the economy working. We may not be that far apart. I think there’s a global learning here and the learnings I’d like to see are how to balance deaths whilst keeping the country open. So PPE manufactured here, continued development of vaccines and treatments etc and a robust plan that considers how we keep going, keep freedoms whilst protecting people going forwards. I just dislike the constant anti-U.K. sniping from some on here. It’s really bloody jarring. Edited by Helmet46 (13 Oct 2021 8.55am) You sound sensible. I think when so many people die and more money is spent than on world wars that an inquiry is just about a necessity. As just what would come from it in terms of accountability and practical lessons I'm my usual skeptical self. In terms of the scale this pandemic is definitely a black swan event though possibly not quite as black swan going forward (lets hope I'm wrong on that). Indeed, it could be argued that the knowledge that there would be an inquiry and that their actions would be hyper focused upon might have hindered some decisions rather than helped....but that's my speculation. This was and still is a test for the entire system and as such reveals strengths and weaknesses, some of which we already knew before it happened. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Oct 2021 10.10am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Oh look… The population density in the United Kingdom is 281 per Km2 (727 people per mi2). The population density in Ireland is 72 per Km2 (186 people per mi2). You would have to show me the science proving such a massive correlation. The data does not appear to strongly support you
|
|
|
Originally posted by Helmet46
Not quite. I probably wasn’t overly clear in how I articulated my thoughts. I think we need an enquiry to understand what mistakes were made and how to ensure we learn from them (and take ownership - an apology not a kick in as none had done this before). BUT I fully appreciate and accept that decisions had to be made quickly and we absolutely had to keep the economy working. We may not be that far apart. I think there’s a global learning here and the learnings I’d like to see are how to balance deaths whilst keeping the country open. So PPE manufactured here, continued development of vaccines and treatments etc and a robust plan that considers how we keep going, keep freedoms whilst protecting people going forwards. I just dislike the constant anti-U.K. sniping from some on here. It’s really bloody jarring. Edited by Helmet46 (13 Oct 2021 8.55am) Do not confuse anger at a truly awful current Government with sniping at the UK. And if you don’t believe the Government is poor as hell, why not take take into consideration the words ‘worst public health failure ever’. And believe me, I saw that up close and personal.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
You would have to show me the science proving such a massive correlation. The data does not appear to strongly support you Not sure what you’re trying to prove here.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Do not confuse anger at a truly awful current Government with sniping at the UK. And if you don’t believe the Government is poor as hell, why not take take into consideration the words ‘worst public health failure ever’. And believe me, I saw that up close and personal. Yeah, but hindsight is always easy, as none of us have been through this before. Common sense is a cinch when you are a witness to the outcome. Of course, as I keep saying, they made horrific mistakes - some terrible and costly and I lost people because of it. But with furlough etc many people, other members of my family included, retained both an income and a job. There is one member of my family who has mental health issues and had it not been for furlough, I have no doubt that the loss of his job and his income would have resulted in the loss of his life. You have to have balance. Learn from the mistakes and ensure you polish the positives. And I would swallow that anger narrative if those posters just had anger at a Govt. as you state. However the same people have spent the last couple of years digging voters out and scoffing at them about their Brexit voting choices - sometimes from homes overseas. So not just the Govt. I get people don’t like the Govt - I’m not much of a fan and didn’t vote for them or Brexit - but I can’t actually remember a Gov’t I did like. However if my perception is that the posts are constantly sniping at the UK then, rather than take the view that I’m confused, maybe review and consider how posts are written and may be perceived? Edited by Helmet46 (14 Oct 2021 7.19am)
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I have some scepticism about the approaches adopted by the UK Government and businesses. Never grip a sh!t!
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
A neighbour told me this last night. He got a call from Track and Trace a couple of weeks ago. Caller: you have to self isolate, now I need you to answer some security questions. Neighbour: no, I don’t know who you are give me some details first. It then went back and forth eventually my neighbour said unless you tell me the details of this COVID contact I am not co-operating. Caller. You were on a flight from Berlin to London. Neighbour. Actually I wasn’t, I booked a return flight from London but never left the country, never checked in at London or Berlin and never completed a passenger locator form. In short I cancelled the flight so there was no contact. Now I will answer your questions (no point, caller agreed he didn’t need to self isolate). Summary: Why the secrecy? He wasn’t asking for the personal details of the person in the next seat just simply where and when they were very reluctant to tell him. What is the point of passport control, check in and the passenger locator form if the data for any of them had been used they wouldn’t have contacted him. So if you are contacted by Track and Trace demand to know the where and the when, if it is correct of course you should self isolate but make them divulge first as their data is unreliable. PS Interesting. Maybe there are data protection issues that make them hesitant to say what they know. This is a good heads up though, because if your neighbour that just gone with it what a waste of time that would've been. As for the app, to be honest whether right or wrong, after I had Covid I deleted the app on the understanding that it was going to be remarkably difficult to get Covid again for several months and so pointless isolating even if I was pinged. It's a shame their systems, and indeed the testing (the recent 45k+ false negatives) was not more accurate. At this point with the low deaths and relatively high case numbers though, Im just assuming that the vaccine combined with natural infections has very much done its job. Let's hope they get into gear regarding the booster shots for those most vulnerable.
|
|
|
Fear and bulls*** getting cranked up. Most people not taking any notice.
COYP |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Fear and bulls*** getting cranked up. Most people not taking any notice. Yes, using a standard of deaths as a number to go by they are remarkably low considering the number of cases (depending on what you go on likely 40-70,000 cases a day, with high hundreds of thousands of active cases) . As far as I'm concerned the vaccine has done its job. Also, surface case number of infections isn't all that it seems really because almost half of the cases are amongst under 20s on account that they mostly haven't been vaccinated (and i'm not saying they should be). I can't see the government changing tack now as there are so many consequences already panning out that this would further worsen.
|
|
|
PJW on where we are currently.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
A high attack rate of 90% of SARS-CoV-2 Delta variant infections in crew personnel on a single navy ship ROK Navy Ship off the west coast of Africa. "272 soldiers out of the 301 soldiers (90.4%) were infected with severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) Delta variant of concern (VOC) on a single navy ship. The navy ship, with the soldiers, departed from a harbor in the Korean peninsula, East Asia on February 8, 2021, and headed towards the mission location.1 During the mission in the Gulf of Guinea, the ship stayed at a harbor in the mission location from June 28 to July 1, 2021.1 The first report of a symptom occurred on July 2, 2021. The accumulated numbers of confirmed cases of SARS-CoV-2 Delta VOC infections were reported to be 6, 247, and 272, on July 14, 16, and 26, respectively." None were vaccinated so it provides an interesting case study thats more akin to situations at the start of the pandemic with previous varients. 0% mortality, as we'd hope in the young. 7% were however hospitalised, and 2.2% severely ill. It brings home how easy it is for health services to buckle due to covid. The above was the eventual tally of this incident: [Link]
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
In Major Shift, NIH Admits Funding Risky Virus Research in Wuhan - [Link] Quote On Wednesday, the NIH sent a letter to members of the House Committee on Energy and Commerce that acknowledged two facts. One was that EcoHealth Alliance, a New York City–based nonprofit that partners with far-flung laboratories to research and prevent the outbreak of emerging diseases, did indeed enhance a bat coronavirus to become potentially more infectious to humans, which the NIH letter described as an “unexpected result” of the research it funded that was carried out in partnership with the Wuhan Institute of Virology. The second was that EcoHealth Alliance violated the terms of its grant conditions stipulating that it had to report if its research increased the viral growth of a pathogen by tenfold.
The NIH based these disclosures on a research progress report that EcoHealth Alliance sent to the agency in August, roughly two years after it was supposed to. An NIH spokesperson told Vanity Fair that Dr. Fauci was “entirely truthful in his statements to Congress,” and that he did not have the progress report that detailed the controversial research at the time he testified in July. But EcoHealth Alliance appeared to contradict that claim, and said in a statement: “These data were reported as soon as we were made aware, in our year four report in April 2018.” The letter from the NIH, and an accompanying analysis, stipulated that the virus EcoHealth Alliance was researching could not have sparked the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, given the sizable genetic differences between the two. In a statement issued Wednesday, NIH director Dr. Francis Collins said that his agency “wants to set the record straight” on EcoHealth Alliance’s research, but added that any claims that it could have caused the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic are “demonstrably false.” EcoHealth Alliance said in a statement that the science clearly proved that its research could not have led to the pandemic, and that it was “working with the NIH to promptly address what we believe to be a misconception about the grant’s reporting requirements and what the data from our research showed.” But the NIH letter—coming after months of congressional demands for more information—seemed to underscore that America’s premier science institute has been less than forthcoming about risky research it has funded and failed to properly monitor.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
High-risk Covid gene more common in South Asians - [Link] Quote University of Oxford scientists have uncovered a gene that doubles the risk of lung failure and death from Covid.
They say 60% of people from South Asian backgrounds and 15% of people of European ancestry carry the high-risk version of the gene. Vaccines are key and help significantly reduce these risks, researchers say. The Nature Genetics study sheds light on why some communities in the UK and South Asia are at higher risk from Covid - but does not fully explain it. Building on previous genetic work, researchers used a combination of artificial intelligence and new molecular technology to pinpoint the exact gene - called LZTF1 - responsible for the increased risks. They estimate the risky version of the gene is present in about 2% of people from African-Caribbean backgrounds and 1.8% of people of East Asian decent. Lead researcher Prof James Davies said the discovery that the risky gene does not affect all populations equally was very important. But he said a complex mix of factors - including age in particular - contributed to each person's individual risk.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.