You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 6 of 44 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
kev64 Flag Cambs 05 Dec 18 4.17pm

Originally posted by Willo

I's sure supporters will be filled with glee and re-assured after reading what Hodgson has said :

"At the moment, we have a number of attacking players, and [Christian] Benteke is not too far away. [Jordan] Ayew, [Alexander] Sorloth and [Connor] Wickham are all training every day and trying to get into the team"

-.-' -.-' -.-'

Where do I sign up, I’ll be more than happy to attend training kick a ball about a bit and never actually make it into the team or god forbid score a goal for 30 to 120k a week

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Dec 18 4.28pm

I suspect the £60+ million spent on transfers under the reigns of Allardyce and De Boer had a significant impact to the extent that under Hodgson the likes of Jach,Rakip,Sorloth etc have been signed.And I suspect it is still having an impact.

Hodgson looks at his bench and sees no real game changers and these are the parameters within which he is working.

Edited by Willo (05 Dec 2018 4.32pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Dec 18 4.42pm

THE board will be negligent if they are at least not considering other options.
Hughes kept Southampton up last year and Jovanacic did an outstanding job las year getting Fulham promoted.
Both have been replaced and there has been no clamour or outrage as the decisions were understandable.
Both clubs have similar records to Palace this season and neither manager was getting the best out of their resources.
It’s not like Huddersfield, Cardiff and Burnley who have limited resources.
If results don’t improve before Christmas the board may have to act despite Roy being a local chap and decent fellow.
And it’s difficult to accept the argument , ‘but who would come in ?’
Do we want another Pardew situation where it’s allowed to drift?

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 05 Dec 18 4.56pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

For me it's Parish.

He's outlasted all the managerial appointments he's made and yet we continue to struggle and it doesn't matter who the manager is.


In anything other than a football club he would be held accountable.



All owners /chairman of football clubs outlast their Managers of course, but as you say, its the chairman who hires the manager,so i guess the buck lands on his desk, however, any time a club hires a manager their is a risk whoever the club or manager

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Dec 18 5.04pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

THE board will be negligent if they are at least not considering other options.
Hughes kept Southampton up last year and Jovanacic did an outstanding job las year getting Fulham promoted.
Both have been replaced and there has been no clamour or outrage as the decisions were understandable.
Both clubs have similar records to Palace this season and neither manager was getting the best out of their resources.
It’s not like Huddersfield, Cardiff and Burnley who have limited resources.
If results don’t improve before Christmas the board may have to act despite Roy being a local chap and decent fellow.
And it’s difficult to accept the argument , ‘but who would come in ?’
Do we want another Pardew situation where it’s allowed to drift?

When Hughes took over Southampton they were not in the same position as we were when Hodgson took over.We were rock-bottom had lost all 4 games without scoring and Hodgson's first 5 games contained matches against Man C,Man Utd and Chelsea.It has been well documented that we lost all of our first 7 games,without scoring a goal, a PL first.Hodgson kept us up against all the odds.

When Hughes took over at Southampton they were outside the relegation zone in 17th and they finished the season in 17th place.

Edited by Willo (05 Dec 2018 5.16pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Dec 18 5.09pm

Do you think Palace should not be considering other options and let the season drift if results don’t improve then ?

 

Glazed Over Flag Sevenoaks 05 Dec 18 5.16pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Them having a player sent off probably helped them, they just put 10 men behind the ball and scored two more goals

Edited for accuracy.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 05 Dec 18 5.20pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

THE board will be negligent if they are at least not considering other options.
Hughes kept Southampton up last year and Jovanacic did an outstanding job las year getting Fulham promoted.
Both have been replaced and there has been no clamour or outrage as the decisions were understandable.
Both clubs have similar records to Palace this season and neither manager was getting the best out of their resources.
It’s not like Huddersfield, Cardiff and Burnley who have limited resources.
If results don’t improve before Christmas the board may have to act despite Roy being a local chap and decent fellow.
And it’s difficult to accept the argument , ‘but who would come in ?’
Do we want another Pardew situation where it’s allowed to drift?


The Jokanovic situation is very different to RH. Jokanovic did well last season but messed up by not having faith in the players who earned promotion and spent a lot on loads of fresh faces which unsettled the squad. He ballsed up in the end.

The Hughes situation is more similar except that Palace are actually playing quite well on the whole, whereas Southampton have a few handy strikers and are crap.

If results don’t improve, he’ll eventually have to go, but I’m very confident they will.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Dec 18 5.21pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Do you think Palace should not be considering other options and let the season drift if results don’t improve then ?

I don't believe that as things stand they are considering any options at all.Hodgson has a lot of credit in the bank for keeping us up last season against all the odds and we are hardly in the relegation zone and cut-adrift.Besides, significant sums of money haven't been lavished on players whilst he has been in charge.

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 05 Dec 18 5.43pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

THE board will be negligent if they are at least not considering other options.
Hughes kept Southampton up last year and Jovanacic did an outstanding job las year getting Fulham promoted.
Both have been replaced and there has been no clamour or outrage as the decisions were understandable.
Both clubs have similar records to Palace this season and neither manager was getting the best out of their resources.
It’s not like Huddersfield, Cardiff and Burnley who have limited resources.
If results don’t improve before Christmas the board may have to act despite Roy being a local chap and decent fellow.
And it’s difficult to accept the argument , ‘but who would come in ?’
Do we want another Pardew situation where it’s allowed to drift?


You know there is a difference between succession planning which is good and lining up the next short term replacement. Hodgson is a good manager, would you have wanted Hughes in the summer if not why would you want him now.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

Boxers Flag Oxford 05 Dec 18 5.50pm

For me Roy has to change his tactics as if you keep doing the same thing you will get the same result. I'm just not sure he can.

Zaha and Townsend are best when running at defenders not standing with their back to them as strikers, hoping one of the 4 center midfielders we are playing in a very narrow system can do something different and supply the ball for them to run on to or attack in the box.

Zaha attracts 2 or 3 players when coming from a deeper/wider position which opens up space and time for the other players.

Roy persists in playing our best two players at running with the ball up top and is making them ineffective.
We can't keep saying we are unlucky, we need to change something. One of our 2 fit strikers should play upfront so at least our two best forwards can play where they have the most impact.

Edited by Boxers (05 Dec 2018 5.51pm)

Edited by Boxers (05 Dec 2018 5.51pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Dec 18 6.01pm

Certainly don’t want Hughes.
The central point is that we are underperforming badly.
The back four are probably as good as anything outside the top 6.
People were worried about losing Luka to a Champions League club in the summer his form was so good.
We have solid experienced premier league players like Mcarthur, Kouyate and Townsend.
We have the jewel in the crown in Zaha and supposedly one of the best young players in Europe in Meyer.
I am fed up of seeing an inflexible one size fits all approach with players being shoehorned into positions where they don’t naturally play to fit in with Roy’s 4-4-2 system.
I am not advocating that Roy goes now but if the pattern of the early months of the season continues then the board need to be in a position to have a potential replacement.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 05 Dec 18 6.40pm

Originally posted by boo909

The balls up of the tranfer windows is a huge problem but the above, our lack of consistency and Roy's snail's pace reaction to changes in the game (if he reacts at all) are the more worrying problems that may not be solved by a good transfer window. Personally I think there must be something wrong in our training regime somewhere too. I think we're really missing Sammy Lee, letting him go (I don't know the facts tbh so it may have been unavoidable) was a mistake.

I have a worrying feeling that Roy is taking it easy and just working through his last season before retirement (lack of support from the board could also be contributing to this).


Edited by boo909 (04 Dec 2018 11.20pm)

You may be right. The only thing that the players seem to be picking up in training at the moment is injuries.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

chateauferret Flag 05 Dec 18 6.51pm

Originally posted by Willo

I don't believe that as things stand they are considering any options at all.Hodgson has a lot of credit in the bank for keeping us up last season against all the odds and we are hardly in the relegation zone and cut-adrift.Besides, significant sums of money haven't been lavished on players whilst he has been in charge.

Now equal second with Spiritu Santo in the sack race at 6 / 1; usual t*** is favourite, of course.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 05 Dec 18 6.58pm

I think we have been riding our luck for too long papering over the cracks that are clearly there.

We need a major striker and not another cheap unknown gamble.

We are way too predictable and far too defensive. We are relying on 2/3 players out of 11 to provide all of our creative flair and that is another reason why we are not causing problems.

It was an absolute disgrace last night but after only 10 minutes you could see it coming. We were unable to string more than 3 forward passes together and were constantly giving it away and inviting Brighton to attack us. We made a very average side look good and there was no heart, organisation or ability on show.

I pray this is the kick up the backside we needed but sadly I expect pretty much the same formation and tactics and we will get beat again.

And as for Zaha, looking at last night I would not be surprised if he has made his mind up and will ask for a transfer in January!

This could be a very difficult time for the club and even if we manage to survive again you can almost guarantee it will be the same again next year.

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

davehuggins Flag 05 Dec 18 7.17pm

Very depressing again this season eh!!

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 05 Dec 18 7.27pm

i blame the 30 million quid wasted on Broken Benteke.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 05 Dec 18 7.35pm

Originally posted by Boxers

For me Roy has to change his tactics as if you keep doing the same thing you will get the same result. I'm just not sure he can.

Zaha and Townsend are best when running at defenders not standing with their back to them as strikers, hoping one of the 4 center midfielders we are playing in a very narrow system can do something different and supply the ball for them to run on to or attack in the box.

Zaha attracts 2 or 3 players when coming from a deeper/wider position which opens up space and time for the other players.

Roy persists in playing our best two players at running with the ball up top and is making them ineffective.
We can't keep saying we are unlucky, we need to change something. One of our 2 fit strikers should play upfront so at least our two best forwards can play where they have the most impact.

Edited by Boxers (05 Dec 2018 5.51pm)

Edited by Boxers (05 Dec 2018 5.51pm)

TBF an awful lot of people on here were urging him to play zaha and townsend up top. Worked well against burnley, but on the whole doesn't work.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 05 Dec 18 7.38pm

Even when benteke was fit he was playing zaha off him up top, looking isolated and in no way as influential as he should be and as bad as benteke has been converting chances, to be fair to him hodgson has never set us up to play to his strengths. He quite clearly can't get the best out of these players and won't even attempt to change things up.

Our wage bill is huge and I can't see there being a substantial amount to spend in January so id get rid of hodgson. Nearly every pundit says palace are too good to go down, that in itself says we have the talent and are under performing. Still think there will be 3 teams worse than us at the end of the season but I'm getting fed up and bored of these meaningless seasons now.

Zaha will 100% leaving in the summer. Ask yourself this question. Would you want to honestly watch this football under hodgson without zaha in our team because I wouldn't, it would be abysmal.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 Dec 18 7.49pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Certainly don’t want Hughes.
The central point is that we are underperforming badly.
The back four are probably as good as anything outside the top 6.
People were worried about losing Luka to a Champions League club in the summer his form was so good.
We have solid experienced premier league players like Mcarthur, Kouyate and Townsend.
We have the jewel in the crown in Zaha and supposedly one of the best young players in Europe in Meyer.
I am fed up of seeing an inflexible one size fits all approach with players being shoehorned into positions where they don’t naturally play to fit in with Roy’s 4-4-2 system.
I am not advocating that Roy goes now but if the pattern of the early months of the season continues then the board need to be in a position to have a potential replacement.

Good post, totally agree.

 

Page 6 of 44 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?