You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Interesting Brexit read
November 21 2026 10.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Interesting Brexit read


Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
cryrst Flag The garden of England 05 May 21 5.04am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I respect that view, but some, indeed many, hardline Brexiteers were wanting out at any cost. For them the very notion of us being part of the EU is an anathema and re-entry in any circumstances unthinkable.

We are probably closer in our views than you might imagine. I saw the need for change but wanted to achieve it from within. Now the baby has been thrown out and the bathwater running down the drain.

The difference being that I look over the fence occasionally!

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 05 May 21 7.19am

Originally posted by Matov

I think a European only military alliance to replace NATO is a good idea. Europe disgracefully hides behind the US when it should be paying for its own defences but who is actually going to attack it?

Russia has the GDP of Spain. Since the end of the Cold War NATO has expanded right up to its borders, despite promising it would not do so.

Russia represents ZERO threat to Europe in terms of any kind of conventional military conflict.

I would have zero problem with the UK being part of this European alliance but lets not pretend that Russian tanks are somehow going to be pouring over the borders and making for Berlin.

But the trouble is that the EU is a trading block. You are talking about a “European Army” as though Europe is one country. It is a continent made up of a number of countries and that’s the problem, in my view. I give it 30 years and the EU will either be the ‘nation’ or will have lost many countries. What should perhaps happen is that it should look at Brexit, consider the reasons and ask itself if it needs to reform, slow down or change. It is too arrogant to do this, sadly.

To me it is absolutely clear that the ambitions of Brussels go well beyond a simple trading block. It will control taxes, access and economies as well as armies and air forces.

Personally I think the EU, with it’s current ambitions and leaders such as Macron - is looking like a potentially dangerous entity and, had it remained purely as a trading block - a collection of individual, friendly countries engaging in free trade and free movement - it would be perfect. That it needed a body to look after the collective trading interests when negotiating externally is clear but it didn’t need a parliament, a flag, a president. As I keep saying it is the direction of travel that I find most worrying here. (And I voted remain but have reflected, considered and reviewed over the last few years).

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 05 May 21 7.31am

Here’s an example of your caring, sharing EU. Threatening to cut off electricity to an Island in a pandemic. Regardless of whether they will or won’t the rhetoric is fantastic and all in the name of the EU. Imagine if this f***er had the might of an EU Army behind him. God only knows what wholly disproportionate stuff he’d try to do or is an historically weak France simply the little kid standing at the back shouting ‘yeah, get him John’ in a scrap?

Obviously we have to honour our agreements and take a look at ourselves but .....

[Link]


Edited by Helmet46 (05 May 2021 7.50am)

 

Orange1290 Flag 05 May 21 7.54am

Originally posted by Helmet46

Here’s an example of your caring, sharing EU. Threatening to cut off electricity to an Island in a pandemic. Regardless of whether they will or won’t the rhetoric is fantastic and all in the name of the EU. Imagine if this f***er had the might of an EU Army behind him. God only knows what wholly disproportionate stuff he’d try to do or is a historically weak France simply the little kid standing at the back shouting ‘yeah’ in a scrap?

Obviously we have to honour our agreements and take a look at ourselves but .....

[Link]


Edited by Helmet46 (05 May 2021 7.49am)


That's just a unilateral threat/action from France and has nothing to do with the 'EU'. As a sovereign nation, France or in fact any other country within or outside of the EU can take any action it sees fit. In fact that's been seen on multiple occasions during the pandemic when sovereign nations who are EU members and within the Schengen zone, closed their borders, absolutely zilch to do with the EU.

You're just showing your 'little England' hatred of the EU.

I give you 1/10, can try better but probably not capable.


Edited by Orange1290 (05 May 2021 7.55am)

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 05 May 21 8.12am

Originally posted by Orange1290


That's just a unilateral threat/action from France and has nothing to do with the 'EU'. As a sovereign nation, France or in fact any other country within or outside of the EU can take any action it sees fit. In fact that's been seen on multiple occasions during the pandemic when sovereign nations who are EU members and within the Schengen zone, closed their borders, absolutely zilch to do with the EU.

You're just showing your 'little England' hatred of the EU.

I give you 1/10, can try better but probably not capable.


Edited by Orange1290 (05 May 2021 7.55am)

Oh aren’t you a little bitch? A troll getting rattled? Maybe they’re showing their hatred of the UK. We know they are not the UK’s greatest fans.

It’s this paragraph where it states “Europe.” He brought Europe into it in his quote. And he shouldn’t have and didn’t need to - hence my comment about France. But we (Jersey/UK) are part of Europe so he’s not only an idiot but another who cannot select appropriate language.

“Europe, France has the means - that's written in the deal.”

"With regards to Jersey, I would remind you, for example, of electricity transmission by underwater cable. So, we have the means. Even if I would regret getting to that point, we will if we have to."

I appreciate accuracy and facts aren’t your strong points, as shown yesterday, but I had rather hoped for a little more intelligence.

Edited by Helmet46 (05 May 2021 8.57am)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 May 21 8.14am

Originally posted by Orange1290


That's just a unilateral threat/action from France and has nothing to do with the 'EU'. As a sovereign nation, France or in fact any other country within or outside of the EU can take any action it sees fit. In fact that's been seen on multiple occasions during the pandemic when sovereign nations who are EU members and within the Schengen zone, closed their borders, absolutely zilch to do with the EU.

You're just showing your 'little England' hatred of the EU.

I give you 1/10, can try better but probably not capable.


Edited by Orange1290 (05 May 2021 7.55am)

Morning PP, lots of active on the bridge woke you up?

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 05 May 21 9.20am

Originally posted by cryrst

The difference being that I look over the fence occasionally!

So do I but I also climb hills and gaze into the distance so I have some idea what might arrive in time.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 05 May 21 9.23am

Originally posted by cryrst

Is this a forcast or your 'take' on it.

I don't think anyone can forecast what might happen in this area with any degree of confidence so this is only an alternative scenario that seems plausible.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Orange1290 Flag 05 May 21 9.29am

Originally posted by Helmet46

Oh aren’t you a little bitch? A troll getting rattled? Maybe they’re showing their hatred of the UK. We know they are not the UK’s greatest fans.

It’s this paragraph where it states “Europe.” He brought Europe into it in his quote. And he shouldn’t have and didn’t need to - hence my comment about France. But we (Jersey/UK) are part of Europe so he’s not only an idiot but another who cannot select appropriate language.

“Europe, France has the means - that's written in the deal.”

"With regards to Jersey, I would remind you, for example, of electricity transmission by underwater cable. So, we have the means. Even if I would regret getting to that point, we will if we have to."

I appreciate accuracy and facts aren’t your strong points, as shown yesterday, but I had rather hoped for a little more intelligence.

Edited by Helmet46 (05 May 2021 8.57am)

And there lies the problem, people like you still fail to understand the difference between Europe and the EU, simple primary school level knowledge and no doubt you voted for brexit with that lack of knowledge. I meet many British immigrants like you who say the UK "left Europe, isn't it great". Unbelievable but a true reflection of the uneducated levels of those who think they 'took back control
but at least it provides us with good entertainment. It's almost turned into a kind of sport when we meet them.


Edited by Orange1290 (05 May 2021 9.31am)

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 May 21 9.40am

Originally posted by Orange1290

And there lies the problem, people like you still fail to understand the difference between Europe and the EU, simple primary school level knowledge and no doubt you voted for brexit with that lack of knowledge. I meet many British immigrants like you who say the UK "left Europe, isn't it great". Unbelievable but a true reflection of the uneducated levels of those who think they 'took back control
but at least it provides us with good entertainment. It's almost turned into a kind of sport when we meet them.


Edited by Orange1290 (05 May 2021 9.31am)

What do you mean “ people like him”? Please explain to us the great unwashed. Your reply sums up the attitude of many remoaners. Holier than thou attitude, claims that those that voted Brexit were all uneducated racists. At least most on here don’t continually slag off the English, you really must have some gripe with this country, lucky you left isn’t it

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 05 May 21 9.43am

Originally posted by the silurian

1.We are not reentering....and adopting the Euro is a requirement of entry
What is the point of 'associate ' terms? Thought you wanted to reform from within? As associates we would surely be unable to do that? You really think Macron and Merkei will just say welcome back on the same terms? No they will try and punish the UK for having the temerity to leave...but it isnt happening (unless weak as piss Starmer becomes PM and that aint happening either!

Edited by the silurian (04 May 2021 9.28pm)

You have no more idea of what the future may hold than anyone else. We could re-enter. The EU could collapse. We could all be obliterated in a nuclear catastrophe.

If we re-entered it would follow negotiations. As, in my opinion, we would never accept the single currency my guess would be that would be a pre-condition to those negotiations.

That would likely mean that we would be re-entering a reformed EU. One with a looser structure and probably created to accommodate those who desired ever closer integration and those who don't.

The idea of a "two-speed" Europe has been around for at least 40 years and will, I think, eventually be the model that is settled on. Should we re-enter we would almost certainly be part of the second, outer, group. Quite possibly the leading member of that group. That's what I mean by an associate member. It's all speculation but the fact remains that it is a very possible future outcome.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 May 21 9.49am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

You have no more idea of what the future may hold than anyone else. We could re-enter. The EU could collapse. We could all be obliterated in a nuclear catastrophe.

If we re-entered it would follow negotiations. As, in my opinion, we would never accept the single currency my guess would be that would be a pre-condition to those negotiations.

That would likely mean that we would be re-entering a reformed EU. One with a looser structure and probably created to accommodate those who desired ever closer integration and those who don't.

The idea of a "two-speed" Europe has been around for at least 40 years and will, I think, eventually be the model that is settled on. Should we re-enter we would almost certainly be part of the second, outer, group. Quite possibly the leading member of that group. That's what I mean by an associate member. It's all speculation but the fact remains that it is a very possible future outcome.

With the out of control Chines rocket heading towards earth, your first paragraph may be very near the mark ( let’s hope not)


[Link]

Edited by Spiderman (05 May 2021 9.50am)

 

Orange1290 Flag 05 May 21 9.53am

Originally posted by Spiderman

What do you mean “ people like him”? Please explain to us the great unwashed. Your reply sums up the attitude of many remoaners. Holier than thou attitude, claims that those that voted Brexit were all uneducated racists. At least most on here don’t continually slag off the English, you really must have some gripe with this country, lucky you left isn’t it


Well, for a start I'm not a 'remoaner', 'brexiteer' or any other group you would like to associate me with. My views are as a British citizen viewing the country from outside looking in. Who's 'slagging off the English'? Not me, where did I say that? Who mentioned that 'those who voted brexit were all, uneducated racists'? Oh, look, it was you, not me.

You seem incapable of defending anything you say and as I said previously, when faced with facts you simply pass them by. Trying to plant an negative 'image' on someone by claiming things that they never actually said is just a sign of someone who is incapable of adding anything to a discussion and is angry at realising that fact.

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 05 May 21 10.03am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

There has never been any "bleating"! Despair at the regressive attitudes of some people and disdain of their insistence it would all work out in the end. Yes to both. Where does it get me? In the same mess as everyone else but still with a determination to do all I can, modest though it may be, to mitigate the worst impacts in the time I have left. Not for me. It will make little or no difference to my life. For my family and the country I love.

You are full of s***.

You lambasted me for speaking out against continued mass immigration because it was a lost cause and here you are whining on about BREXIT. Your hypocrisy is only matched by your capacity for self delusion.

Instead of spending your remaining days resisting, why don't you see that both issues are part of the same problem. Britain is being undermined by creeping globalism. Its culture, its sovereignty, everything that we recognize as British.
BREXIT was a spanner in the works for that trend and next we have to tackle the insane number of immigrants entering Europe if anyone actually cares about preserving our heritage.
The globalists and here today gone tomorrow politicians don't care. They think short term gain is all that matters.
You obviously agree with them.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 May 2021 10.05am)

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 05 May 21 10.03am

Originally posted by Orange1290

And there lies the problem, people like you still fail to understand the difference between Europe and the EU, simple primary school level knowledge and no doubt you voted for brexit with that lack of knowledge. I meet many British immigrants like you who say the UK "left Europe, isn't it great". Unbelievable but a true reflection of the uneducated levels of those who think they 'took back control
but at least it provides us with good entertainment. It's almost turned into a kind of sport when we meet them.


Edited by Orange1290 (05 May 2021 9.31am)

You really are an idiot. Read my post again. HE spoke of Europe when he clearly meant the EU - that was exactly what I was articulating. This is what I said:-

It’s this paragraph where it states “Europe.” He brought Europe into it in his quote. And he shouldn’t have and didn’t need to - hence my comment about France. But we (Jersey/UK) are part of Europe so he’s not only an idiot but another who cannot select appropriate language.

This clearly implies he meant the EU but said Europe. So, in reality, a French politician cannot distinguish the difference whereas I clearly did, hence calling him out on that.

You seem incapable of understanding basic English or you are so entrenched in your pro EU world that you neither read nor understand.

As stated in a previous post - which you also clearly didn’t read - I voted remain. My views are purely concern over the direction the EU project is now taking. I’ve said that countless times, but you ignore what you cannot answer.

You have, once again, proven yourself to be lacking in too many basic skills for any form of rational and educated debate. You speak of facts but you keep getting them wrong and when you’re called out on them you squirm.


Edited by Helmet46 (05 May 2021 10.08am)

Edited by Helmet46 (05 May 2021 10.10am)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 May 21 10.03am

Originally posted by Orange1290


Well, for a start I'm not a 'remoaner', 'brexiteer' or any other group you would like to associate me with. My views are as a British citizen viewing the country from outside looking in. Who's 'slagging off the English'? Not me, where did I say that? Who mentioned that 'those who voted brexit were all, uneducated racists'? Oh, look, it was you, not me.

You seem incapable of defending anything you say and as I said previously, when faced with facts you simply pass them by. Trying to plant an negative 'image' on someone by claiming things that they never actually said is just a sign of someone who is incapable of adding anything to a discussion and is angry at realising that fact.

Your posts have been very negative, am I the only one to think that? How gave I not defended anything I have said? I defended the BF staffing but you chose not to accept my explanation( your prerogative). I asked why you travelled during a pandemic, which you have neither admitted or denied ( whose avoiding what now?).
You have questioned posters intellect on more than one occasion.
As you criticise me for not defending my points, what did you mean by “people like him”?

 

becky Flag over the moon 05 May 21 10.09am

Gentlemen, can we please stop the personal sniping on this thread?

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 05 May 21 10.14am

Originally posted by becky

Gentlemen, can we please stop the personal sniping on this thread?

Of course and I apologise but I was reacting to insults aimed at me.
But fair comment, it will not happen again.

Edited by Helmet46 (05 May 2021 10.21am)

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 05 May 21 10.16am

Originally posted by becky

Gentlemen, can we please stop the personal sniping on this thread?

Good for you!

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 May 21 10.16am

Originally posted by becky

Gentlemen, can we please stop the personal sniping on this thread?

Certainly I apologise if my posts have been rude and personal

Edited by Spiderman (05 May 2021 10.17am)

 

Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Interesting Brexit read