You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 9 of 44 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Hoof Hearted 06 Dec 16 9.51am

Originally posted by nickgusset

1)You said earlier you listen to all sides of an argument. That's b/s because you openly admit to not reading any counter argument links I post.
2) You've wilfully ignored the fact that 7mins has given info that shows the guard s job is more than just closing doors.
3) If no jobs are being lost, doesn't that point to the fact that the unions gripe is about safety - don't forget, people don't get paid when on strike. Are people losing pay just to be awkward? I very much doubt it.

Have a super day.

I do listen to all sides usually, but yet again I'll remind you (for the last time) why I don't engage with you specifically.

Point 3 above makes my point...... you and other Union blowhards just don't listen.... I've told you that the Independent Rail Inspectorate has signed off on safety, so everyone should now be satisfied. They have listened to all sides, considered it, and given their verdict.

So yes, the RMT union are being awkward and probably compensating the strikers so they don't lose out.

I am bored to tears going over old ground again and again with you. Quite often I start to read what you say and quickly realise it is the same old guff regurgitated.

So. being old also teaches you not to waste precious time on people that will not change their opinions or practices and concentrate on those who might.

Good day to you once and for all.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Dec 16 9.51am

Damn all to do with "Safety and security". Driver Operated Only (DOO) trains are used by many operators around the country and this practice has been in place for many years.

All to do with Union believing that plans are all about saving money and getting rid of staff, privatisation etc etc but they are playing the "Safety and security" card and misleading the public.

No more to say on this as I will only get on my darned "Soapbox" and my blood pressure will rise to dangerous levels.That's me finished in this debate.

Edited by Willo (06 Dec 2016 10.24am)

 

Hoof Hearted 06 Dec 16 9.57am

Originally posted by Kermit8

All I know is that the guards on GWR have a multitude of tasks they are getting on including passenger safety during the many hundreds of times i have journeyed with them.

There is absolutely no way they are not needed down here. The driver could not do what they do as he/she would have to leave their cab.

I can't speak for Southern as have only used them a handful of times.

I'll remind you as well.....

The Independent Rail Inspectorate (IRI) have signed off the driver only operation on Southern having listened to all parties concerned and considering those views and their implications on safety issues.

It's not my opinion, I am quoting a FACT.

As to whether that situation is exclusive to Southern, or could be rolled out to Exeter/GWR I don't know, but if you want your opinion heard, best to pass it on to the IRI for their consideration.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (06 Dec 2016 9.58am)

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 06 Dec 16 10.08am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
Finally, I would suggest that the Rail Industry needs a complete overhaul to try and match the efficiency and safety of the rail systems operated in Japan and Switzerland which everyone knows are the best in the world.
Edited by Hoof Hearted (06 Dec 2016 9.03am)

Not sure Japan is the model of safety and efficiency that's suggested

Japan employ Pushers to cram people onto massively overcapacity trains, stuffing people into absolutely unsafe conditions. It's funny when you see it on a video, it is not funny when you are in it.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Dec 16 10.12am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

I'll remind you as well.....

The Independent Rail Inspectorate (IRI) have signed off the driver only operation on Southern having listened to all parties concerned and considering those views and their implications on safety issues.

It's not my opinion, I am quoting a FACT.

As to whether that situation is exclusive to Southern, or could be rolled out to Exeter/GWR I don't know, but if you want your opinion heard, best to pass it on to the IRI for their consideration.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (06 Dec 2016 9.58am)



"The ORRs committee’s inquiry into rail safety, Dr George Bearfield, the director of system safety at the RSSB, defended the RSSB’s decision to declare DOO safe despite admitting that train companies would still have to carry out individual assessments."

RailTechnolgy Magazine.

So safe up to a point and circumstance but not across the board for Driver Only Operated. Each company/region will have to do their own risk assessments.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


.TUX. Flag 06 Dec 16 10.19am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Unions have default positions for every situation.

That Union guy interviewed this morning on R4 Today sounded like Scargill, McCluskey etc and as you say went straight on the attack claiming it was the start of privatising Network Rail before even considering it's merits at all.

That's why I don't debate with Gusset who is entrenched in Union dogma.

There are no merits to privatising anything related to a countries infrastructure. Taking profits to pay dividends to speculators is just bonkers.

 


Buy Litecoin.

Hoof Hearted 06 Dec 16 10.24am

Originally posted by Kermit8



"The ORRs committee’s inquiry into rail safety, Dr George Bearfield, the director of system safety at the RSSB, defended the RSSB’s decision to declare DOO safe despite admitting that train companies would still have to carry out individual assessments."

RailTechnolgy Magazine.

So safe up to a point and circumstance but not across the board for Driver Only Operated. Each company/region will have to do their own risk assessments.

[Link]

Above is a link to the findings of the "independent rail safety body".

You can read it for yourself,

Edited by Hoof Hearted (06 Dec 2016 10.26am)

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Dec 16 10.26am

Originally posted by .TUX.

There are no merits to privatising anything related to a countries infrastructure. Taking profits to pay dividends to speculators is just bonkers.


Exactly. Shareholders sit on their fat arses and let others do the work for them then take the money that should really be re-invested to make fares cheaper, have more stock, enough staff, enough upgrades, etc.

Privatising public utilities into regional monopolies is one of the many ugly faces of capitalism. Punishing the majority in order to cash benefit the already wealthy few.

Saw a train fare from Devon to Manchester for £600 return a few months back. How has that situation been allowed to even come about?

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Dec 16 10.29am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

[Link]

Above is a link to the findings of the "independent rail safety body".

You can read it for yourself,

Edited by Hoof Hearted (06 Dec 2016 10.26am)


I know. I am just saying by its own admission it is not all-encompassing. Even they can't say all DOO trains would be safe so neither can you nor I.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Hoof Hearted 06 Dec 16 10.36am

Originally posted by .TUX.

There are no merits to privatising anything related to a countries infrastructure. Taking profits to pay dividends to speculators is just bonkers.

Graylings suggestion that Network Rail and the Train companies get together to discuss maintenance problems etc was part of this mornings announcement and was rejected out of hand too.

Grayling also confirmed that his announcement had nothing to do with privatisation of Network Rail (NR) or any suggestion of it.

What he said was NR are inundated with work at the moment so he has sanctioned a private contractor to upgrade an old ex Beeching cut BR line on the east coast to speed up improvements to service in that region. The line work is self contained and any work necessary to connect it up with existing track will be carried out by NR.

So.... yet again Unions stirring up sh1t to get the gullible public onside.

 

Hoof Hearted 06 Dec 16 10.39am

Originally posted by Kermit8


I know. I am just saying by its own admission it is not all-encompassing. Even they can't say all DOO trains would be safe so neither can you nor I.

They are arse covering much like when we used to finish off reports with E&OE.... do people still do this?

I haven't seen a report for a while.

 

gambler Flag Kent 06 Dec 16 11.00am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

[Link]

Above is a link to the findings of the "independent rail safety body".

You can read it for yourself,

Edited by Hoof Hearted (06 Dec 2016 10.26am)

Ah, do you mean the "independent" rail safety body whose Directors include none other than "Charles Horton, Chief Executive Officer, Govia Thameslink Railway Ltd".

Not exactly independent is it?

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Dec 16 11.02am

Originally posted by gambler

Ah, do you mean the "independent" rail safety body whose Directors include none other than "Charles Horton, Chief Executive Officer, Govia Thameslink Railway Ltd".

Not exactly independent is it?


Dept. of Transport appoints the committee members too. Having said that it is non-ministerial so does have supposed independence.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Hoof Hearted 06 Dec 16 11.10am

Originally posted by gambler

Ah, do you mean the "independent" rail safety body whose Directors include none other than "Charles Horton, Chief Executive Officer, Govia Thameslink Railway Ltd".

Not exactly independent is it?

It is accepted by all those that matter as Independent.

Why have you only cited one person?

Bodies of this sort canvass opinion from all stakeholders involved in the industry and you would expect someone of Charles Horton's ilk to be involved.

When the RMT sit down and discuss policy do you think they have a politically neutral bias, or are they all lefties?

If you can show that the rail safety body is unduly biased and has come to the wrong conclusion I will take your post seriously.

Otherwise I will overlook it as guff.


Here is a list of the Board of the RSSB...

[Link]

These names mean nothing to me.

I see their decisions are audited though but I'll guess you'll throw suspicions of bias at the auditors too?

Edited by Hoof Hearted (06 Dec 2016 11.19am)

 

Hoof Hearted 06 Dec 16 11.13am

Not bad for an old Tory duffer of 62 with Parkinson's.....

I've seen you all off today single handed.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 06 Dec 16 11.25am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Not bad for an old Tory duffer of 62 with Parkinson's.....

I've seen you all off today single handed.

Not bad 7.5/10.

Had to put you right about DOO trains and your 1975 vote but you can't be expected to remember or know everything.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Hoof Hearted 06 Dec 16 11.29am

Originally posted by Kermit8

Not bad 7.5/10.

Had to put you right about DOO trains and your 1975 vote but you can't be expected to remember or know everything.

I like you Kermy.

X

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 06 Dec 16 12.02pm

I love the way that reportsfrom independent bodies about brexit being bad are nonsense and to be taken with a pinch of salt yet anyone questions the rail report they are thick.

Double standards methinks.

 

gambler Flag Kent 06 Dec 16 12.03pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

It is accepted by all those that matter as Independent.

Why have you only cited one person?

Bodies of this sort canvass opinion from all stakeholders involved in the industry and you would expect someone of Charles Horton's ilk to be involved.

When the RMT sit down and discuss policy do you think they have a politically neutral bias, or are they all lefties?

If you can show that the rail safety body is unduly biased and has come to the wrong conclusion I will take your post seriously.

Otherwise I will overlook it as guff.


Here is a list of the Board of the RSSB...

[Link]

These names mean nothing to me.

I see their decisions are audited though but I'll guess you'll throw suspicions of bias at the auditors too?

Edited by Hoof Hearted (06 Dec 2016 11.19am)

Oh come on hoof, you linked to the findings of a so called independent body re safety. Whatever side of the argument you sympathise with, in no way can the body be called independent when at least one member has a conflict of interests.

 

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 06 Dec 16 12.19pm

A friend took this picture on the train last night, can see why they are needed.

thumbnail_IMG_0025.jpg Attachment: thumbnail_IMG_0025.jpg (86.46Kb)

 

Page 9 of 44 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong