This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall
Totally on the fence regarding the HF, but while its currently now to slag them off, please remember at times our home support has been painfully bad. I don't think anyone has forgot what happened, but, this is about people handing over their money to something that should've happened at the West Ham game on the 21st April. They then say they won't do it unless they get to put a banner up.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by mart.denman
Perhaps if the HF stopped wearing the black " I'm in a gang" uniform & wore club colours like most then wouldn't need flags as would be quite colourful without them, like the Bayan Munich game the other night. A few flags at one end which didn't add much, but the fact that nearly everyone was in club colours made a big difference & was noticeable And at Dortmund last night! Everyone and everything was kitted out in yellow and was just WOW!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by eritheagle
And at Dortmund last night! Everyone and everything was kitted out in yellow and was just WOW!! Not to forget the years that the Dutch have been turning whole sides of whatever stadium they play in orange - always an amazing sight.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
Overall I am in favour of the HF in terms of what they bring to the match day experience / party- however what does irk me is that whenever they feel that something is not going their way they seem to feel that the best course of action is to try to put a metaphorical gun to the clubs head to force the outcome that they want - i.e - if you don't do this (move seats / reinstate banner) it dosent feel like a negotiation it feels like blackmail. At least from the outside / what gets written - maybe I am wrong, for sure I am not in the room when these things are discussed - but thats how it feels. I agree
|
|
|
Originally posted by EaglesEaglesEagles
I agree with a fair bit of what's been said about the HF, especially surrounding their idea of special treatment and representation as some sort of unique voice of Palace fans. Nonetheless I think the move from Block B to the middle has been a good thing. The whole of Block E and most either side in D and F stand for an entire game which creates a more intense, supportive atmosphere. Their displays in the past have been very organised as well, not to mention impressive. Try telling that to the hundreds of established fans that sat there, wanted to remain there and were forced by the club to move.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NICK THE EAGLE
Wow it’s been a few months since I came on to look at what’s going on. The last time I did it was all about our little friends dressed in black. It’s very simply a case of”We told you so” It didn’t take a genius to work out that the move from B to was never going to improve the atmosphere. When the move was very first muted, I said that the good sound generated was assisted by the low hanging Arthur roof which In turn helped the volume travel around the stadium. By moving to Block E it simply dissipates into a concrete overhang then into the air. I still stand in B and truthfully apart from the drum we rarely hear them sing. Getting back to this topic. Personally I wouldn’t pay into anyone’s account as you cannot be certain what that money is being used for. The only time I did was for the brilliant 2 cocks tifo which involved the entire Holmesdale. I honestly think the group has been in a very steep decline since those days. With them it’s always been a case if you don’t play our game I’m taking the ball home. I agree that there hasn't been a great deal of improvement with the move - yet. My guess is that the long term vision was/is that once the new stand is built most people will want to move into it, which will free up loads of seats. At the same time, the lower tier will (hopefully) become a safe standing area where those who want to sing for 90 minutes will congregate around the HF and expand the section. Personally, I love what they do on the whole. I haven't been to many games over the past couple of seasons - mainly due to a lack of interest/mid table boredom - but I'll always make an effort to get to the cup games to be in/near the HF. Makes the whole experience much more enjoyable for me. The atmosphere in the rest of the ground is pretty drab, so would rather watch at home and save the money. Must say the banner unveiled at Arsenal was poor. It didn't represent the view of most Palace fans and was an embarrassment. My only gripe is that they seem to consider themselves the voice of all Palace fans.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
I agree that there hasn't been a great deal of improvement with the move - yet. My guess is that the long term vision was/is that once the new stand is built most people will want to move into it, which will free up loads of seats. At the same time, the lower tier will (hopefully) become a safe standing area where those who want to sing for 90 minutes will congregate around the HF and expand the section. Personally, I love what they do on the whole. I haven't been to many games over the past couple of seasons - mainly due to a lack of interest/mid table boredom - but I'll always make an effort to get to the cup games to be in/near the HF. Makes the whole experience much more enjoyable for me. The atmosphere in the rest of the ground is pretty drab, so would rather watch at home and save the money. Must say the banner unveiled at Arsenal was poor. It didn't represent the view of most Palace fans and was an embarrassment. My only gripe is that they seem to consider themselves the voice of all Palace fans. I dunno about that. I would imagine most people sitting behind the goal are used to the view and wouldn't want to move. I'm in the Arthur and personanlly I don't like watching a game from behind the goal. As for the whole money, flags and where's it gone chat, well if nothing happens and no refunds are given without good explanation, then people simply won't contribute financially next time. If it's because of the banner then IMHO the HF are essentially saying that it's more important they get their banner put back up, than the goodwill of the rest of the fans and that'll break some trust that will be very hard to get back. Edited by SnapperKain (07 May 2024 5.30pm)
The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots |
|
|
Originally posted by SnapperKain
I dunno about that. I would imagine most people sitting behind the goal are used to the view and wouldn't want to move. I'm in the Arthur and personanlly I don't like watching a game from behind the goal. As for the whole money, flags and where's it gone chat, well if nothing happens and no refunds are given without good explanation, then people simply won't contribute financially next time. If it's because of the banner then IMHO the HF are essentially saying that it's more important they get their banner put back up, than the goodwill of the rest of the fans and that'll break some trust that will be very hard to get back. Edited by SnapperKain (07 May 2024 5.30pm) I agree, if the flags don’t appear at Villa, that isa disgrace
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
I agree that there hasn't been a great deal of improvement with the move - yet. My guess is that the long term vision was/is that once the new stand is built most people will want to move into it, which will free up loads of seats. At the same time, the lower tier will (hopefully) become a safe standing area where those who want to sing for 90 minutes will congregate around the HF and expand the section. Personally, I love what they do on the whole. I haven't been to many games over the past couple of seasons - mainly due to a lack of interest/mid table boredom - but I'll always make an effort to get to the cup games to be in/near the HF. Makes the whole experience much more enjoyable for me. The atmosphere in the rest of the ground is pretty drab, so would rather watch at home and save the money. spot on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by twcpfc
Lots of people on here are rightfully questioning the go fund me. The flags have been ordered. It's up to the club to make a small concession and restore the banner - something that clubs such as chelsea/man utd have in their grounds - clubs with a bigger advertising potential than us. A banner that was previously fine and recognises decades of hard work in the stadium and behind the scenes to support the club, and the noise generated by the stand and stadium - which has earned a rightful reputation and has been used for marketing purposes by the club countless times. I believe it is at the stage where Parish is (hopefully) trying to finalize getting it back up, as everything is cleared with the ground staff and operations level. It's extremely annoying not having the banner and a whole stand of flags present for some of our best home performances and I hope it can be back for the villa game with a top atmosphere to round the season off. Though you say people are rightfully questioning the fund raiser you still seem to support the HF stance on the banner . They are separate issues and should not have been linked in any way whatsoever . The banner was great and I hope they can get it back up but the HF have gone about it in an arsupward way that doesnt win them any brownie points for any future fundraisers .
|
|
|
Originally posted by twcpfc
Lots of people on here are rightfully questioning the go fund me. The flags have been ordered. It's up to the club to make a small concession and restore the banner - something that clubs such as chelsea/man utd have in their grounds - clubs with a bigger advertising potential than us. A banner that was previously fine and recognises decades of hard work in the stadium and behind the scenes to support the club, and the noise generated by the stand and stadium - which has earned a rightful reputation and has been used for marketing purposes by the club countless times. I believe it is at the stage where Parish is (hopefully) trying to finalize getting it back up, as everything is cleared with the ground staff and operations level. It's extremely annoying not having the banner and a whole stand of flags present for some of our best home performances and I hope it can be back for the villa game with a top atmosphere to round the season off. Man Utd and Chelsea haven't had digital advertising installed on the front of their top tiers (as far as I know) like Palace have and therefore don't get monies from companies advertising on it. And you have just confirmed other people's previous posts that have been critical with your 'club need to make a small concession' comment which is basically a big banner advertising a small group of 20-40 in a stadium of 25-26,000. J
|
|
|
Originally posted by twcpfc
Lots of people on here are rightfully questioning the go fund me. The flags have been ordered. It's up to the club to make a small concession and restore the banner - something that clubs such as chelsea/man utd have in their grounds - clubs with a bigger advertising potential than us. A banner that was previously fine and recognises decades of hard work in the stadium and behind the scenes to support the club, and the noise generated by the stand and stadium - which has earned a rightful reputation and has been used for marketing purposes by the club countless times. I believe it is at the stage where Parish is (hopefully) trying to finalize getting it back up, as everything is cleared with the ground staff and operations level. It's extremely annoying not having the banner and a whole stand of flags present for some of our best home performances and I hope it can be back for the villa game with a top atmosphere to round the season off. So, the flags have been 'ordered', they were supposed to be available for the WH game on the 21st April, we have had 2 more home games since then. WHY, do the club have to make a concession? What the club do with THEIR ground is entirely up to them. Think the hf need to be a bit more respectful, as others have said, you are losing/lost support among the majority of the fan base, they will realise that next time they want peoples hard earned money.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by twcpfc
Lots of people on here are rightfully questioning the go fund me. The flags have been ordered. It's up to the club to make a small concession and restore the banner - something that clubs such as chelsea/man utd have in their grounds - clubs with a bigger advertising potential than us. A banner that was previously fine and recognises decades of hard work in the stadium and behind the scenes to support the club, and the noise generated by the stand and stadium - which has earned a rightful reputation and has been used for marketing purposes by the club countless times. I believe it is at the stage where Parish is (hopefully) trying to finalize getting it back up, as everything is cleared with the ground staff and operations level. It's extremely annoying not having the banner and a whole stand of flags present for some of our best home performances and I hope it can be back for the villa game with a top atmosphere to round the season off. I think you might of shot yourself in the foot here as essentially this is an admission that the HF is holding the club to ransom over the banner, but also that people's money has been collected (and used) without full disclosure of what the intention was (i.e. would only be used if the club agree to the banner coming back). We didn't give money for the flags for that to then be used as a negotiating tactic with the club about the banner and I say that despite being in support of the banner being reinstated. We though the flags would be used at West Ham and my impression was that they would be reusable for the rest of the season. What your saying is that this hasn't happened because it's being used as a pawn in getting the club to reinstate the banner. If the HF used the display as a bargaining chip with the club before collected the money then that would have been fine, but not afterwards. Not cool man.
The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.